From Rich Wyler, Director, Brothers Road —
In my opinion, the subtitle of the classic book No More Mr. Nice Guy could almost be:
“Lessons (Nearly) Every Man with Same-Sex Attraction Needs to Learn.”
In fact, there’s a line from one of Brothers Road’s experiential healing workshops where the mythical “Hideous Damsel” — a part of the psyche that tells uncomfortable truths — chides participants:
“Women don’t want NICE GUYS. Women want WHOLE MEN.”
While that line is directed at heterosexual dynamics, the underlying truth lands just as strongly — and sometimes even more painfully — for men who experience some degree of same-sex attraction.
Let me offer a concise summary of Dr. Robert A. Glover’s core ideas, followed by my reflections on why they resonate so deeply for many SSA men.
The Core Idea
Dr. Glover argues that many men who see themselves as “nice” are actually stuck in a hidden pattern of people-pleasing, conflict avoidance, and suppressed needs. This pattern often leads to resentment, passive behavior, sexual frustration, and weak boundaries.
The book is not about becoming harsh or selfish. It’s about moving from covert, approval-seeking “niceness” to authentic, grounded masculinity.
The “Nice Guy” Pattern
Men caught in this pattern often unconsciously believe:
“If I am good, helpful, agreeable, and self-sacrificing, then I will be loved, appreciated, and finally get my needs met.”
When this unspoken bargain fails — which it almost always does — anger, entitlement, and bitterness emerge, often without the man fully understanding why.
Nice Guy behavior frequently includes:
-
Chronic people-pleasing
-
Fear of conflict or disapproval
-
Hiding needs, desires, and flaws
-
Difficulty asking directly for what they want
-
Passive-aggressive anger
-
Weak or inconsistent boundaries
-
Sexual repression or compulsive sexuality
On the surface, Nice Guys appear generous. Internally, they are often keeping score.
Where This Pattern Comes From
Glover traces Nice Guy behavior back to childhood environments marked by:
-
Emotionally unavailable, critical, or unpredictable caregivers
-
Conditional love (“You’re good when you behave”)
-
Lack of safe male role models
-
Learning that anger, need, or sexuality were unsafe or shameful
The child learns a survival strategy:
“If I don’t rock the boat, I’ll be accepted.”
That strategy may keep a child safe — but it quietly sabotages adult intimacy.
The Hidden Cost
Over time, Nice Guys often experience:
-
Dead bedrooms or sexual frustration
-
Being taken for granted
-
Chronic resentment
-
Addictive or compulsive behaviors (porn, affairs, substances, work)
-
A sense of invisibility or lack of purpose
Ironically, the very behaviors meant to secure love end up undermining respect, attraction, and connection.
Key Shifts the Book Teaches
From Approval-Seeking → Self-Approval
Stop managing how others see you. Start acting in alignment with your values.
From Indirect → Direct
Nice Guys hint and hope. Healthy men ask clearly — even when the answer might be “no.”
From Hidden Anger → Conscious Anger
Anger isn’t the problem. Unacknowledged anger is.
From Enmeshment → Boundaries
Healthy men learn to say:
-
“No.”
-
“That doesn’t work for me.”
-
“I want something different.”
Without apology or justification.
From Sexual Shame → Sexual Integrity
Nice Guys often split sexuality into “good” and “bad.”
The invitation is toward honesty, integration, and responsibility.
Why This Book Resonates So Deeply with SSA Men
This is where No More Mr. Nice Guy takes on particular relevance for men with same-sex attraction.
Many SSA men learned early that being agreeable was safer than being authentic. Approval — especially male approval — felt scarce and high-stakes. As a result:
-
People-pleasing often attaches not just to women, but to men
-
Approval-seeking can become sexualized
-
Male friendships feel confusing or risky
-
Boundaries feel threatening because belonging feels existential
-
Sexuality becomes split between “acceptable” and “shameful”
For many men I’ve sat with, the Nice Guy pattern isn’t about manipulation — it’s about survival. But what once protected them now quietly keeps them stuck.
What the Book Is Not
It’s important to say clearly what No More Mr. Nice Guy is not:
-
Not anti-kindness
-
Not misogynistic
-
Not about becoming aggressive or dominant
-
Not a license to stop caring about others
It’s a call to stop abandoning yourself in order to be loved.
Bottom Line
No More Mr. Nice Guy invites men to:
-
Stop hiding
-
Stop bargaining for love
-
Stop outsourcing their worth
And instead:
-
Live honestly
-
Act directly
-
Take responsibility for their needs, desires, and boundaries
For many men — especially men with SSA — the book is confronting because it names patterns they’ve felt for years but never had language for.
And naming the pattern is often the first step toward freedom.